Thank you for your response.
Correct. but [a feature requests exist](https://github.com/Prowlarr/Prowlarr/issues/407); you can also do it via the API
a feature requests does not mean it will ever be implemented.
Not sure where or what gave you that impression. [Custom YML is supported](https://wiki.servarr.com/prowlarr/indexers#adding-a-custom-yml-definition)
As you can see from that link at the time of my initial comment that page did not exist hence why me or anyone who was looking would think that you can not create your own indexers. As you can also see some of that documentation is wrong. As its missing jail installation. FYI for a jail installation you have to create Custom dir in this path /usr/local/prowlarrdotnet/Definitions/ and then add your .yml there.
Where did you look? Did you look at the [wiki](https://wiki.servarr.com/prowlarr/)? It doesn't appear so based on your comment. We have significantly more documentation than Jackett.
Every where. Jackett has documentation for installation on FreeBSD considering this thread was created to help people install prowlarr suggests that your mistaken about prowlarr having better docs than jackett. Please note i am also including third party docs such as blogs, tutorials etc.. in this. Also at the time of my comment ye did not have documentation for custom indexer while jackett did. These are just a few things i searched for. The was many more things i was searching for documentation on that i could not find and had to figure out. If you have custom use cases for jackett/prowlarr you will find far more information regarding jackett than you will with prowlarr. This is more than likely due to jackett being around a lot longer. Im sure in time prowlarr will have documentation on par with jackett.
Third party guides are maintained and created by the community - be the change you wish to see.
Prowlarr does of course have a quickstart guide on the wiki.
This quickstart guides are more targeted at arr users. For jackett there is a lot more documentation for people using custom application/use cases and if its not in the documentation then you will be able to find it on blogs, reddit etc.. Again im sure this will change in time.
Again, not sure where or what gave you that impression. Prowlarr provides a newznab or torznab endpoint for every indexer. This is the same that Jackett does (with Prowlarr supporting usenet as well) [This is also on the wiki](https://wiki.servarr.com/prowlarr/indexers#viewing-an-indexer-id-or-url)
I dont think that docs is anywhere on par with what jackett have or what you can find on jackett. Again there was a reason this thread was created. There is step by step in jackett on how to get torznab, rss feeds etc...
Prowlarr is not trying to be Jackett, so that's just an opinion there.
I understand that I am just making a point that in my opinion it is overly complex for what it does and it seems to be targeted at arr users. If you use arr apps then great go for Prowlarr. If you need something that can integrate with other solutions like qbittorrent, custom app etc.. then you will find far more info on jackett.
Faster, stats, usenet support, has an actual dev team behind it (Jackett has no devs only 2 or 3 `contributors` who do what they can)
I tested a search of 70+ torrent indexers(which took forever to enable with Prowlarr) with both jackett and prowlarr and found little to no speed difference. Im talking max a second or 2. I have no need for usenet or stats. I can generate stats using the logs very easily.
In regards to dev team. Any feature or bugs i found were resolved pretty quickly with jackett so im not sure your point is valid.
Considering you created an account on here to just respond back to my post it would seem pretty clear that your view is NOT impartial. In my post i have provided an impartial view of the prowlarr and all the facts i said were correct at the time. Just to be clear here i am not bashing prowlarr or jackett. I just gave a fair view of why i prefer jackett. Things could change and i could prefer it in the future. Also currently all those points in my post except #2 are still valid.
If you want to provide the benefits of Prowlarr vs Jackett then please create
a new thread doing so instead of commenting on a thread about installing it.